Friday, September 5, 2008

"Masterpiece" Game Design

(I had a lot of extra time during my break today, so I took out my notebook and jotted down some thoughts regarding game design philosophy.)

I don't want to just make a "popular game". Yes, that can be important, if not simply for fiscal reasons, but if game designers want their creations to be taken seriously as art, shouldn't they be more conscious of what experience they initiating for the player? Designers need to go beyond cookie-cutter genre games and creating games that simply change how people think about games, and start creating games that change how people think-- and feel. I believe that's the marker of a true masterpiece. If we want games to join film and literature as "high art", we should consider making this a more dominant goal.

How? It's not as simple as making a game "fun". Fun isn't a series of meaningful choices-- how would we explain literature, moves, and rythm/reflex games? They can be fun but involve no real choice. Rather, I perceive fun as the enjoyment of appealing aesthetics. In that way it's completely subjective and that's why there's no universal "fun". Trying to make a fun game is just as futile as trying to make a good game. If you want fun, look to the MDA framework and aim for something aesthetically cohesive.

Aesthetics inspire the "feel" of a game. Aesthetics span more of game development than the design, as they're accomplished through more than mechanics and systems (e.g., strategy, sensation, agency, evolution); they're found in visuals, narrative, and sound as well (e.g., eroticism, rythm, drama, confliction), and even through the interface (there is a tactile aesthetic to iPod games, or even card games). Some aesthetics are accomplished through several different channels.

Genre games are popular specifically because the genres are sort of aesthetically cohesive. "Sort of" in that not all genre games are, but the best of them that really define the genres are. If you must make a genre game, consider the aesthetics which really shine in that genre. What do players want to experience in that genre's games? Remember, it's the experience that makes the game, not the features.

Next to consider are themes. In conceptualization, themes are like the other half, aside from aesthetics. While aesthetics are the "feel", themes are the "thoughts"-- they're the context, subject matter, and also what the player carries from the game into the real world. Sexuality, crime, vengeance, and war are examples of themes. Narrative genres can also be interpreted as themes-- high fantasy, science-fiction, etc., though they can be broken down into more specific sub-themes (transhumanism, magic, biological warfare, etc.).

Some things are hard to distinguish as aesthetics or themes. It depends on the approach of the game design. For example, eroticism and sexuality. Eroticism is an aesthetic in that the goal is to appeal to prurient interests. Sexuality, on the other hand, is a them in that it explores sexuality within the human condition. Another example is something like honor. Honor can be an aesthetic if you can make the player feel the honor somehow (this is very challenging). It can also be a theme if the game experience explores issues surrounding honor.

What are the approaches of experience-driven design? Well, it first depends on the desired aesthetics and themes, and which are the core of the project. Sometimes there are mostly only aesthetics (many genre games) or mostly only themes (e.g., license games). In the case of mostly only aesthetics, an aesthetically-driven approach would be taken, with themes being used as tools to drive the aesthetics. On the other hand, game projects with mostly only themes would choose aesthetics which went hand-in-hand with the themes. And then, there are game projects of a mixed approach, where the aesthetics and themes may not be related, but are equally important as core goals for the end experience.

Designers have tools they can use to accomplish aesthetics and themes-- gameplay paradigms, mechanics, dynamics, input devices, GUIs, character design... the list goes on. The content of the game-- narrative, visuals, audio-- can also be used to accomplish aesthetics as well as themes, and should be considered carefully.

Remember scope, though-- a long list of aesthetic and thematic goals is not necessary to make an appeasing game, and can overcomplexify the project, bringing focus away from central points. Rather, aim first for a cohesive experience, with all the aesthetics and themes tying into eachother nicely. Depth before breadth. If you can bring in more breadth while keeping it cohesive, then go for it. Just remember that as there is feature creep, there can be aesthetic and thematic creep as well!

Finally, publishers need to realize that there's a market for masterpiece games. Masterpieces have long-lasting appeal that span decades and high-replayability simply because the experience is of such high caliber.

No comments: