Friday, September 28, 2007

Game Mechanic Gripes (+much more griping)

I originally posted this on MMORPG.com, as a response to a forum post.

The topic is, things you hate about MMOGs.

The "MMO" genre. Before you bash me, let me explain. =]

MMO is a technology. Being able to play online is something you can take advantage of. However, it's not a genre. RPG is a genre. FPS is a genre. RTS is a genre. But adding MMO in front of these does not make them a different genre. Sure, MMO technology may change the way a genre is played, but a genre is defined by the very core game mechanics. In RPGs, it's character advancement, for example. And if you think carefully, you'll notice that more and more games are getting online capabilities. It's very possible that in 10 years, there will only be online games.

However, players will not always want to play socially. There will always be those who like to play by themselves, for whatever reason. It's usually because they don't like dealing with other people, or they like to immerse themselves and feel they can do this better without interruption or complication added by other players. I understand that people playing a game in a "single-player" way is annoying to some people, but why? Is this really explainable beyond the whole "MMOs are supposed to be multiplayer" thing? Like I said, MMO is a technology, and if someone is having fun in their own way without hurting the experience of other players, why should they be ridiculed?

Instead games should facilitate both styles of game play. People are going to feel like doing both at one point or another. In fact, if developers utilized both to their potential, games could be a lot richer. People often complain that MMOs don't focus enough on story. In single-player parts of a game (instanced, perhaps), the story could be brought to life without the factor of influences or interruptions made by other characters. Think about what makes single-player games great. It's obviously the story, the detail, the individual behavior of characters, the movie sequences, etc. You can't achieve these in a multiplayer setting because there is no central control. You can't interact with this other character in a special scene because 10 other people are trying to do the same. This is when instancing and single-player gameplay should be utilized. (I think Age of Conan may be doing something like this.)

In conclusion, I think the industry just needs to break out of the MMO restraints. Go back to the traditional genres and offer the "MMO" as a feature. This could be a contributing factor to ending the production of endless WoW/EQ clones (which many of us are familiar with).

WoW/EQ Clones and the Overrated Labeling of Genres, etc.

I won't be as elaborate on this peeve. I'm really tired of all the WoW/EQ clones. I find it depressing that if you look at the UIs of several new games, they all look like WoW! What's up with that? I'm also getting tired of the same old "level-up by gaining experience points". This is not the only way of character advancement! I understand that this is easy for the typical gamer, and that it's a surefire way to get a large userbase, but why can't game developers try to create some more niche games for those who don't want to play WoW anymore?

Like I said, I think the industry needs to break out of the whole MMO thing. I definitely think that will free things up quite a bit. Look how single-player games are evolving: TESIV: Oblivion, Final Fantasy XIII, Kingdom Hearts. These are all RPGs, but they offer several different ways of playing the game in both combat and character advancement. In Oblivion, it's what's commonly considered "skill-based" (though it does have levels). FFXIII has a really spiffy looking "attack chain" concept going on, which could potentially speed up and fancy-mafy RPG combat. KH is an RPG but it's very actiony. MMOs should try to be more creative and original like these games are being.

Of course, the general idea is that the real key to success in MMOs is to balance the old with the new. Use what you know works, and add in only enough originality to where your users aren't confused. However, I don't really agree with this. I think this is only supporting the "cookie-cutter design" methodology. Everyone is going to immediately think, "WoW is what works. We'll base our game off of that." WoW is undeniably an excellent game, but instead of clearly copying its game mechanics, developers should instead try to create something new and exciting.

I'll be honest. I'm a dorky hopeless aspiring game designer. I'd like to think that I have potential but in such a competitive field, who knows if I do? But I do know one thing: I don't like all the labeling. I don't like the constraints they create. I don't like the "MMO" label because it minimizes the single-player style of gameplay. I don't like the ESRB ratings. I don't even really like the traditional genres when they are forced onto games-- most successful games nowadays don't even fit into a particular genre. RPGs are gaining action/adventure elements. And TESIV: Oblivion has got some FPS stuff going on as well. I think much more creativity can be unleashed if developers free themselves from these design constraints.

If I ever design a game, I'll do my best from trying to stuff it into some generic genre, "MMO", or ESRB rating box. These things shouldn't be constraints on a game like technology and funding are. They are just preventing a flow of creativity. Designing for a target audience is important, yes, but breaking the audience line is a way to success as well. Understandably this is quite complex, but basically, a truly fun game is going to draw in people who weren't originally its intended audience. I think the only audiences that should be designed for are age groups (the ESRB isn't quite fair, so don't hop on me for mentioning age groups here), and educated vs uneducated (e.g., literacy, technology skills). Possibly also political/religious/cultural views.

Quite trying to develop an MMORPG or an FPS or whatever-- just try to make a fun game. You can take some "inspriation" from other games, and perhaps take the core mechanics of a genre and put your own twist on it, but don't try to copy successful games just for the sake of making a profit. Making a profit is important, but when you are providing a gaming experience to your customers, you are providing them with a service. That service should be something new and exciting and above all, fun, not pretty much the same thing they can get from WoW. Because if they want WoW, they'll play WoW, and not your copy-cat game. >_>

Okay, I got elaborate. So shoot me.

Some other general peeves:

  • Lack of customization options in characters' physical appearance. I could go on for ages on this. For this, Sword of the New World sucks.
  • Lack of free motion and interaction with the environment (e.g., swimming, jumping, climbing, etc.). Again, Sword of the New World sucks.
  • Lack of emotion (have you ever seen someone cry in an MMOG? What about romance?).
  • Lack of mature/adult MMOGs (yay for Age of Conan). I'm an adult, I can deal with, deserve, and prefer content for my age group.
  • Stigmatization/banning of cybering. First note, I don't cyber, and I probably never will (as I'm in a fulfilling relationship), but I try to have an open mind. The fact is that cyber-sex is a safe way for people to relieve sexual pressure, without risk of STDs or pergnancy, and without the pressure of a relationship. Think it's a loser thing to do? I'd rather be a loser than get someone pregnant or get a fatal STD by having sex in person. It shouldn't be allowed in games, but the attitude regarding it needs to change.

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

From LEGOs to Games: Customizing Virtual Worlds

I used to play with LEGOs. I had sooooo many LEGOs. Me and my brother shared them and we'd build all kinds of stuff. We inherited a lot of them from our dad, so we had some old ones too. I've always liked role-playing. Even I'd use the little LEGO characters and create my own adventures and such. It was so much fun.

In a way, this can be contrasted to many social games of today, such as WoW, etc. You can create your own character, and customize its appearance. LEGOs let you do that. But LEGOs also go one step further and leave the rest of the creative process up to you as well. You create the world you play in too. You create the story. All you get are the building blocks, and the rest is up to your imagination and how long you want to dedicate to it.

A lot of people wonder why we can't do something completely like this in a social game successfully. Well, we can do the character part, but when it comes to the world-- it's best to leave it to the developers for the most part. In what I call social games (commonly called MMOGs or social networking sites like Gaia Online that have game elements), there are thousands or millions of people playing. The physical world needs to be consistent to a degree so that people can familiarize themselves with areas. If you're always lost in a game, you're not able to strategically make your way through it based on your previous experiences in the game world. There's also the problem of competition among players to customize the world-- everyone is going to have their own idea of what it should be like, and what should be where. Of course, there are also limits, such as the amount of space available to customize, and the fact that a whole engine and system or whatever would have to be worked up for the players to be able to customize the world.

I think, however, that some change is good in a world. While I don't like the idea of players being able to chop down forests or build cities from the ground up, I could see a building or two being added by players-- probably a huge goal for a whole guild or something like that. I could also see specific types of trees being available for players to chop down. But when you make it to where anything can be changed-- you might have to standardize, and whatever way you do it you're probably going to cut down on the artistry of the environment's design quite a bit. I'd prefer the forest to be more lush-- so that it's easier to immerse myself in as my character, but what's the use if nothing lasts so players can appreciate them? A good immersive environment needs to be realistic, and when you combine a lot of simulation with that kind of realistic detail, you're probably going to have more work on your plate than you can handle.

I think though, in perhaps more action-oriented games (or parts of games), that a more flexible environment could add some pizazz. It's always fun to ponder about characters crashing into (or through) buildings, or trees, or boulders.... and other people. =P

When playing games gets dangerous

I'm honestly very skeptical about video game addiction, seeing as how it's a behavior and everything rather than a drug. However, recently a man in China died after playing an online game for 3 days straight. This is not the first time something like this has happened either.

Read more here: Gamespot Article

There is obviously some trend going on in online gaming that causes people to play so recklessly. I blame the players to a degree, for not establishing limits for themselves, but the industry is to blame in a way as well. A lot of MMOs in particular require such a huge time investment, in combination with paying hard-earned money for subscriptions. For people to get the most out of their money, they have to cram in gaming. And in the player-versus-player environment, it's incredibly competitive in that nobody wants to be hindered by not getting the top equipment as soon as possible. They can't relax and play casually, or they'd be wasting their money and falling behind everyone else.

I'm seriously hoping the industry improves. China is already placing limits on online activity. I really don't like the idea, but if people are dying, it's serious. If nothing changes in the industry and no limits are placed (either by the players themselves, the game, or a ruling body like the government), more people are going to game recklessly. There's going to be more people exhausting themselves, not eating, not working, not exercising, and even not taking care of their children.

I think the first and foremost thing that should be done is to break away from the cookie-cutter style of MMORPGs, where the goal is to get the top gear so you can PVP well, which takes a huge amount of time, especially in combination with subscription-based payment methods. Guild Wars is great in that after you buy the game, you never have to pay. I've heard that the game was purposely designed so that it could be "beatable"-- meaning that it doesn't require a huge ongoing time investment. I think this is an excellent idea, and while it doesn't guarantee a flow of profit from the player base, it is one step closer to a better gaming experience. And yeah, gear-oriented games are getting old-- you hear people saying that games are "WoW-clones" or "EQ-clones" all the time now. I'd love to play a game that focused more on player skill, rather than aligning specs right and getting the best equipment.